THE MYSTERY OF THE PANTOMIME CAT
(Egmont, 192 pages)
My first taste of Enid Blyton's mystery and adventure stories was her Five Find-Outers series, when I was about six. I remember thinking what exciting, grown-up lives these children led. Unfortunately, I was not a very good or thorough reader then - so much so that, for a little while, I thought Peterwood was actually a person rather than the village where the five children lived! I guess even then I was given to skimming paragraphs, paying close attention only to passages that I thought looked particularly interesting.
Anyway, although I used to own all 15 of the books in the series, most of them were lost, mainly lent to friends and never seen again! Of our original set of mysteries, only three very tattered copies remain. The Mystery of the Pantomime Cat is inscribed with my name and the date - 1975!!! Amazing that I've owned this book for nearly 30 years, although I have to say that it sure looks its age ;-) ... and the first seven pages are missing :-(
Still, it retains its distinctive cover, with the picture of a large orange pantomime cat staring out of a window. And the illustrations, by Mary Genat, who supplied the drawings for the whole series, are most certainly the basis of how I imagine the Find-Outers to look like.
I am currently in the midst of buying the new Egmont editions (reissued in 2003) and it's good to know that I will soon own the whole set again. However, I'm sorry to see that they do not contain the Genat illustrations. Also, the covers are rather too cartoonish for my liking. It's true that books should never be judged by their covers, but the fact is they are, all the time, and I'm as guilty of the crime as the next person: I think if I didn't already know these were great books, the covers of these reissues would not tempt me to buy them. (By the way, the cover I've used here belongs to the Hamlyn edition.)
Fortunately, the Find-Outers are old friends and I know that despite their new and unattractive appearance, they will not disappoint!
I spent a happy hour, recently, rereading The Mystery of the Pantomime Cat - my favourite Find-Outer book. I think it's much the juiciest of the 15, with the most exciting, least simplistic plot.
As usual, it's the school holidays and the five children (Fatty, Larry and Daisy, Pip and Bets) and Fatty's Scottish Terrier, Buster, have a mystery to solve. However, things get decidedly dodgy when the police are misled by some fake clues, planted by the five.
The crime (a robbery) takes place in a theatre and the suspects, the cast of a pantomime, all have alibis ... or so they say. It's up to the kids to figure out who's telling lies and in order to do that they have to do a lot of snooping, which, of course, infuriates their arch nemesis, Private Constable Goon.
Actually, I've always found the animosity and rivalry between the Find-Outers and the Goon truly tedious, but there are some decidedly comic encounters in this story, not least when Goon keeps bumping into Fatty and the boy's cheeks look fatter and fatter each time!
Another of my favourite bits in this book is when Fatty and Larry disguise as ruffians to fool Goon's colleague PC Pippin. It's very exciting to read about these boys creeping about in the dark and then crouching in the bushes, whispering away and arousing Pippin's suspicions.
I also love the way the Find-Outers devise ways of meeting the suspects and checking out their various alibis. When I was little, it made me want to solve mysteries too and I'm sure my best friend and I went through a phase of planting false "evidence" for members of our family to find!
I don't know if 21st century creations like Digimon will mean that Enid Blyton's books seem pretty tame to kids these days. I'm hoping my sons will find them as thrilling as I did. The fact that there aren't any monsters in these books could actually work in their favour as they make the possibilty of having a similar adventure very real.
As for the horrendous covers, on reflection, I think they're meant to appeal to the below-9 crowd. My seven-year-old doesn't seem to find them ugly. In fact, he's quite taken with the bright colours and, IMHO, bizarre cartoon figures. Oh, well!
In an earlier post I said that you could get find the Mystery books in all good local bookstores. I lied. I've since visited quite a few, including the MPH at Midvalley Megamall, that do not carry these books. The MPH at the new wing of 1Utama does though.
As for Malaysians living outside the Klang Valley, it's best you call your local bookstore and ask if they stock the books to avoid disappointment. And I'm pretty sure you can get any MPH branch to order them for you.
I hope to write reviews of my other favourite Blyton books and if you have a favourite Blyton, do email me your review and I will post it.
In the meantime, here is a list of the 15 Mystery book. Happy collecting!
1. The Mystery of the Burnt Cottage (1943)
2. The Mystery of the Disappearing Cat (1944)
3. The Mystery of the Secret Room (1945)
4. The Mystery of the Spiteful Letters (1946)
5. The Mystery of the Missing Necklace (1947)
6. The Mystery of the Hidden House (1948)
7. The Mystery of the Pantomine Cat (1949)
8. The Mystery of the Invisible Thief (1950)
9. The Mystery of the Vanished Prince (1951)
10. The Mystery of the Strange Bundle (1952)
11. The Mystery of Holly Lane (1953)
12. The Mystery of the Tally-Ho Cottage (1954)
13. The Mystery of the Missing Man (1956)
14. The Mystery of the Strange Messages (1957)
15. The Mystery of the Banshee Towers (1961)
Recent Comments